If you're considering updating your bathtub in Wisconsin, there are several options to explore—from refinishing methods to complete replacement. Each method has its process, cost, and durability, and choosing the one that best suits your needs is essential. Here’s a breakdown of the most common methods: Bath Fitter, spray refinishing, our unique pour-on refinishing process, and total bathtub replacement.
1. What Is Bath Fitter?
Bath Fitter is a popular option for homeowners needing a fast bathroom upgrade. Instead of refinishing or replacing their existing tub, Bath Fitter installs a custom-made acrylic liner.
-
Process:
A custom acrylic liner is measured and molded to fit perfectly over your existing bathtub. Installation is typically done in one day, with minimal demolition required. -
Durability:
Acrylic liners are relatively durable and last 10-15 years. However, because the liner is installed over the existing tub, it won't address those structural issues if there are cracks or damage underneath. Over time, moisture can also get trapped between the liner and the tub, leading to mold or mildew growth. -
Cost:
The average cost of a Bath Fitter installation is between $1,500 and $4,000, depending on the size of the tub and the customization required.
2. Traditional Spray Method Refinishing Wisconsin
The traditional spray refinishing method involves spraying a thin layer of acrylic or enamel over your existing bathtub to restore its appearance.
-
Process:
A technician sprays a thin coat of acrylic or enamel over the tub surface. This process usually takes a day to complete, but because of the strong chemical fumes, homeowners are often advised to leave the house during and after refinishing. -
Durability:
Spray-on coatings are relatively thin and typically last 5-7 years. Over time, the finish may chip, peel, or fade, requiring frequent touch-ups or refinishing. -
Cost:
The cost of spray refinishing is relatively affordable, ranging from $300 to $700. However, given its shorter lifespan, it may require refinishing more frequently.
3. Our Pour-On Refinishing Method
Our advanced pour-on refinishing process offers a more durable and long-lasting solution than traditional spray methods. We apply a single, thick layer of a specialized coating ten times thicker than spray coatings.
-
Process:
A thick coating layer is poured onto the tub and spread evenly across the surface, filling in any chips, cracks, or imperfections. The process is dust-free, odorless, and noise-free, allowing you to stay comfortably in your home during the refinishing. It also cures quickly, typically within 24 hours. -
Durability:
Our pour-on method creates a thick, durable finish that lasts 10-15 years or more. Because of its thickness and strength, it resists wear, chips, and peeling far better than spray methods. -
Cost:
Our pour-on refinishing typically costs between $400 and $750. While it’s a bit more expensive than spray refinishing, its extended lifespan and superior durability make it a more cost-effective choice in the long run.
4. Full Bathtub Replacement
If your bathtub is severely damaged or outdated, a full replacement may be the best option. This involves completely removing your old tub and installing a brand-new one.
-
Process:
Replacing a tub requires the demolition of the old bathtub and the installation of a new one. This process can take 5-7 days or longer, depending on the complexity of the job and any plumbing or tiling work involved. -
Durability:
A new bathtub can last 20 years or more, making it a long-term solution. However, it has a much higher upfront cost and involves a more disruptive renovation process. -
Cost:
Replacing a bathtub typically costs $2,000 to $7,000, including labor, materials, and plumbing. The price can increase if additional repairs or remodeling are needed.
When Should You Replace Your Tub?
You should consider a complete replacement if:
- Your bathtub has severe structural damage, such as deep cracks or leaks.
- You want to change the size or design of the tub as part of a more significant bathroom renovation.
- The existing tub is beyond repair, and refinishing would not be satisfactory.
If your tub is still in decent shape but has surface damage (like scratches, stains, or small chips), refinishing is usually the smarter, more cost-effective option.
Price and Durability Comparison
| Method | Durability | Cost | Process Time | Odor/Fumes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bath Fitter | 10-15 years | $1,500 - $4,000 | One day | None |
| Spray Refinishing | 5-7 years | $300 - $700 | One day | Strong fumes |
| Our Pour-On Refinishing | 10-15 years or more | $400 - $750 | One day | Odorless and dust-free |
| Full Replacement | 20+ years | $2,000 - $7,000+ | 5-7 days | None |
Conclusion: Which Option Is Right for You?
-
Refinishing is best if you want a quick cosmetic update and don’t need significant structural changes. Our pour-on refinishing process offers the best value for money for a longer-lasting, odorless, and durable finish.
-
If you want to avoid demolition and upgrade your bathtub, Bath Fitter offers a middle-ground solution, but it comes with higher costs.
-
Complete replacement is the right choice for major renovations or when structural issues are beyond repair, though it involves a much higher cost and longer process.
To get the best results and extend the life of your tub, we recommend considering our pour-on refinishing process for its durability, odorless application, and long-term cost savings. Call us today at (224) 616-1766 to learn more!
